# Python tip: Inspect function signature at runtime

## Problem:

I have a list of functions with different signatures. There is some set of possible parameters, and I want to call all these functions with the “appropriate” argument for each parameter.

This is a little hand-wavy, let’s look at an example:

def half(a): return a / 2 def twice(a): return 2 * a def addition(a, b): return a + b def subtraction(a, b): return a - b functions = [half, twice, addition, subtraction] a = get_a() b = get_b()

Desired outcome:

[half(a), twice(a), addition(a,b), subtraction(a, b)]

And we want to do this without making our function definitions too ugly.

## Solution 1:

One option is to `get_b()` within the functions that need them. This is not ideal, suppose `get_b` is not a pure function (e.g. a network call), we would want to pass `b` into scope instead of getting it from elsewhere every time it’s needed.

## Solution 2:

We could change the signature to accept arbitrary kwargs and then pass a dict of args, for example:

def half(**kwargs): return kwargs['a'] / 2 def twice(**kwargs): return 2 * kwargs['a'] def addition(**kwargs): return kwargs['a'] + kwargs['b'] def subtraction(**kwargs): return kwargs['a'] - kwargs['b'] functions = [half, twice, addition, subtraction] payload = {'a': get_a(), 'b': get_b()} results = [f(**payload) for f in functions]

This works, but makes each of our function definitions uglier.

## Solution 3:

Allow each function to have a different signature, inspect the signature at runtime and pass what is needed.

(Adapted from http://stackoverflow.com/a/2677263/3393459)

import inspect def half(a): return a / 2 def twice(a): return 2 * a def addition(a, b): return a + b def subtraction(a, b): return a - b # Wrapper which: # * accepts a dict of all possible kwargs and their names # * inspects the signature of the function # * calls that function with the correct args def call_func_with_correct_args(f, possible_args): func_args = inspect.getargspec(f).args args_to_pass = {k: possible_args[k] for k in func_args} return f(**args_to_pass) functions = [half, twice, addition, subtraction] a = get_a() b = get_b() full_payload = {'a': a, 'b': b} results = [call_func_with_correct_args(f, full_payload) for f in functions]

So this is nice and clever, but we need to be careful that our function parameters are named correctly and consistently. Essentially we are passing the burden to the function definitions.

## Conclusion

I don’t know what a great solution to this might look like. Is there a better way to do this? If all the parameters are different types, Python3’s type hinting might provide another option. What does this look like in other languages?

### Comments (0)

### Revision History

(About)